I've had this discussion a few times now, with various people. Let's look at a problem in game design from two perspectives. The problem is rather simple. It deals with resource gathering in an MMO and demonstrates this the best. The basic premise is a player goes to a spot where there should be something to gather (iron, flowers, wood, whatever). Now the challenge is to make the user try to gather on this (and every other spot like it) to try to get resources, maybe multiple ones even from one spot. But there also is a skill check involved to reward those that have been doing it more often.
Let's look at the developer side. You could simply chose a random output, say randomly they fail or get something. Maybe randomize the amount you get from using that resource spot, and/or the amount of time it regenerates, rate it regenerates with, and so on. But since we are developers, we want a better solution than just plain random. So we build up a complicated table, backlog, statistical analysis and so on, and in the end ship it.
Showing posts with label Design. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Design. Show all posts
Monday, October 17, 2011
Monday, April 25, 2011
On trade
I wanted to write something on a different topic, but my mind kept returning to trade, so here we go. Trade has been on my mind a lot lately, because it ties into so many things. Item teleport, information teleport, player teleport, movement speed, resource gathering, crafting, communication, storage, money are just the most screaming topics. There are tons of other ones being influenced by them.
Now two steps back. Trade, what is that? When I talk about trade, I talk about the exchange of information, commodities, services and currency, in any combination possible, between two parties. These parties can include any combination of NPCs and/or players. Me giving a newbie a sword for free, is a trade. A good one for him, a financially not very good one for me, but then again, I might do it to woe the newbie to join my guild. See how those trade things instantly get a bit into everything?
Trade is the under appreciated orphan child of pretty much all games out there. There are exceptions. But few and far in between. The most common one is the item exchange, that happens between two players at the busiest location within the game. The next common one is buying stuff from NPCs. Not very exciting. But trade (especially the player driven kind) can be so much more.
Now two steps back. Trade, what is that? When I talk about trade, I talk about the exchange of information, commodities, services and currency, in any combination possible, between two parties. These parties can include any combination of NPCs and/or players. Me giving a newbie a sword for free, is a trade. A good one for him, a financially not very good one for me, but then again, I might do it to woe the newbie to join my guild. See how those trade things instantly get a bit into everything?
Trade is the under appreciated orphan child of pretty much all games out there. There are exceptions. But few and far in between. The most common one is the item exchange, that happens between two players at the busiest location within the game. The next common one is buying stuff from NPCs. Not very exciting. But trade (especially the player driven kind) can be so much more.
Monday, April 11, 2011
Don't listen to your community
I'm not advocating for ignoring them, but I'm advocating for considering the issue a bit more in depth first. What I mean by listen is really the listening part as in "what is said".
Communities have a very special dynamic and it's a though decision when you try to implement changes or try to decide what to do next. Getting priorities from your community is about as pleasant as having your teeth pulled by a 500 pound gorilla on a unicycle during an earth quake.
Now I apply this with such general terms because it's true for many things, be it websites or video games. I came across this topic though for a game, so let's just run with that. The discussion was about a feature, should it be put in or not. One voice was to look at the community, what are they saying. Instantly alarm bells went up in my head and I didn't distinctly know why. I knew it was a bad idea, but why exactly?
Communities have a very special dynamic and it's a though decision when you try to implement changes or try to decide what to do next. Getting priorities from your community is about as pleasant as having your teeth pulled by a 500 pound gorilla on a unicycle during an earth quake.
Now I apply this with such general terms because it's true for many things, be it websites or video games. I came across this topic though for a game, so let's just run with that. The discussion was about a feature, should it be put in or not. One voice was to look at the community, what are they saying. Instantly alarm bells went up in my head and I didn't distinctly know why. I knew it was a bad idea, but why exactly?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)